HTML5 vs. Flash: Is the Fight Important to the User?

A lot of people are passionately involved in the "one way or the other" debate surrounding Flash and HTML5. Some people contest that Flash is, and will be for some years to come, the most popular and accessible form of bringing media to the masses. Others have put forward the argument that Flash is outdated and incompatible with some modern devices, and HTML5 offers many improvements over Adobe's antiquated format.

What's the right answer? It's simple, if you're a user: it doesn't matter what the answer is Whether you're watching YouTube, a client presentation or a tournament on Partypoker, it's not going to make a huge amount of difference to you as long as the media is brought to your fingertips with ease. A lot of people forget that not everyone is a web developer, so whether that embedded funny video is in Flash or HTML5 isn't going to make the slightest bit of difference to them.

That isn't to imply that the average user is stupid and only enjoys funny videos - that's a generalisation that's only too easy to wield, much to the unhappiness of those being stereotyped. Ironically, it's also this demographic that will ensure your sales keep going up, so not pandering to the PEBKAC, "read the manual" mindset is probably for the best.

If you're wondering which to choose, ask yourself this - which do you enjoy most? Do you like working in Flash, whether everything is familiar and easy to do, or do you find the challenge of a new format with new capabilities exciting? Either way, it's worth being knowledgeable about both, as a HTML5 switch-over is a reasonable possibility.

Looking into the future, there's a lot of turmoil for those who live designing for the web the way it is now. But at the end of it, some of you will adapt, and some of you will die stubbornly. HTML5 and Flash won't take your souls, and neither will those who debate with you. Learn as much as you can, and experiment - and good luck doing so. See you on the other side.

Drag and drop between browsers

I found Leslie Michael Orchard informative on HTML5 drag and drop. If you open it in two (Firefox 3.6.8) browsers you can drag and drop between them. This could be useful in a Content Management System. I made a simple copy to demo the idea.

QuirksMode was very critical of the HTML5 drag and drop specification

HTML5 tags and comparing one CMS to another

I have made a simple page to show some new HTM5 tags that I hope will be useful when comparing one CMS to another.

These can set the definition of section, article etc so we can talk sensibly when discussing different approaches to content management.

Tagcloud example using Flash SWFObject

This tagcloud serves up keywords from the titles of courses offered at a University.

I wonder how useful it is if a user just wanted a broad overview of what was on offer.

WP-Cumulus

It serves up this xml

I presume undergraduates have a general idea and postgraduates have a specific idea of what they want. Is the number of links just too large?

less popular pages

I wrote a very simple CMS (for a university) that was designed to draw traffic to the less popular pages.

Users could enter keywords and create categories that their content belonged in.

An autocomplete search showed visitors that some keywords were not available.

The more popular the category the more clicks it took to drill down to the content.

Keywords distinguished one page from another while categories grouped them together. The category would not appear until at least two content items belonged to it.

This worked because there were not a very large number of content items. Approximately 20 subcategories in 20 categories was about right in this case

BlogCFC was created by Raymond Camden. This blog is running version 5.9.1.002. Contact Blog Owner